223 519 просмотров
964547
Информация о видеоклипе
Nightwish performing Sleeping Sun, Live
SUBSCRIBE to Nightwish YouTube: http://bit.ly/subs-ntwsh-yt
SUBSCRIBE to Nuclear Blast YouTube: http://bit.ly/subs-nb-yt
in Helsinki, Kaisaniemi, 26.6.2008
PURCHASE ALBUMS HERE:
▶ITUNES: http://georiot.co/3nWj
▶AMAZON: http://georiot.co/FUb
CONNECT WITH US:
▶OFFICIAL SITE: http://nightwish.com/en/
▶FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/nightwish
▶TWITTER: https://twitter.com/NightwishBand
▶SUBSCRIBE to Nightwish YouTube: http://bit.ly/subs-ntwsh-yt
▶SUBSCRIBE to Nuclear Blast YouTube: http://bit.ly/subs-nb-yt
#Anette #Emppu #Jukka #Live #Marco #Nightwish #Sleeping #Sun #Tuomas #Highest Hopes: The Best Of Nightwish (Musical Album) #Marco Hietala #Erno Vuorinen #Emppu Vuorinen #Erno Matti Juhani Vuorinen (Musical Artist) #Jukka Nevalainen #Troy Donockley #Anette Olzon #Tarja #Tarja Turunen (Musical Artist) #Nightwish (Musical Group) #tuomas holopainen #floor jansen #imaginaerum #symphonic metal #Metal #Power Metal #heavy Metal #Rock #wacken #official live
Комментарии к видеоклипу
Izayoi Higurashi
08 марта 2016 года в 04:12
17
not bad at all... For Annette's voice is very very good, you have to take in count that she is not a lyric singer, so for her voice whic is her normal voice, is very good, she will not be able to sing the super high part of Tarja's version without a lyrical technic.... and I find her voice beautiful here... I always find her voice not power full for NGHW songs, but in this one, I heard her voice with a little of vibrato and very sweet.... :) :D even though I prefer Tarja's version :3
Сергей Васильковский
31 июля 2016 года в 12:39
She needs a good singing teacher. For performances on the big stage, it is not ready.
Izayoi Higurashi
08 марта 2016 года в 04:16
2:41 I hate when she does this with her voice, is the only thing I cannot forgive her... >.< is horrible. When she makes like a arrengment or something like that... she makes something with her voice that I don't like... but is all about singing skills... I thing she has a beautiful voice with potential but she needs lessons ... even though she is a professional singer, I thing she is wasting her talent
salanee
15 августа 2014 года в 10:20
59
Sun has just killed itself
Vik Delson
30 ноября 2016 года в 23:45
Haters gonna hate
Hamster Munchies
18 июня 2015 года в 20:06
+salanee My ears are close too.
Hamster Munchies
18 июня 2015 года в 20:06
+salanee My ears are close too.
feralkittieh
20 марта 2015 года в 08:36
rofl, best comment I've ever seen on youtube :')
Rasmus Marttila
06 октября 2014 года в 18:18
27
It's not worse, just different!
Absolutny Zwierz
22 января 2014 года в 00:12
15
I love Anette but this song is not for her : /
Ťørɱȩṇ
08 октября 2016 года в 12:41
11
This is one of those songs they shouldn't played with Anette. Absolute insult to original version. Even Floor can't (or doesn't want to) perform this like it should. I would like to hear Floor trying to mimic original version thou, because there is no other way to do this one!
Nevena Peeva
08 января 2017 года в 11:01
Yes, of course, Tuomas writes every song with the singer in mind, but I still think it's not the only way the songs could be done and if the whole band agrees that changing it in a certain way to suit the current vocalist works for the song, then I don't see why they shouldn't do it. (that includes Anette's versions - I mean, we can dislike her Sleeping Sun (for example) all we want, at some point the band was happy with it and there are some fans which might even prefer it)
I guess what I mean is this: it's all about personal preference. I feel like Floor's Sleeping Sun is as good as Tarja's and better than it would have been if she had tried to mimic her, and you think that Tarja's version is better and she should try to sing it like her - and us having different opinions is perfectly okay. :) After all, we both have something to listen to and enjoy, right? ^^
I guess what I mean is this: it's all about personal preference. I feel like Floor's Sleeping Sun is as good as Tarja's and better than it would have been if she had tried to mimic her, and you think that Tarja's version is better and she should try to sing it like her - and us having different opinions is perfectly okay. :) After all, we both have something to listen to and enjoy, right? ^^
jeanawyszk
08 января 2017 года в 04:22
annette and floor have their own way of singing this song but tarja owns this song.....I personally think tuomos wrote songs for each singer. tarja has her own set of songs, annette has her own and floor is coming up with her own. Tuomos is very gifted in writing songs to the type of voice and to be honost I like all three girls equally. Tarja got the band started though and thats what gives the band the credit and success they had. I heard floor sing this song and was not impressed but I think she can do this song better if she knows opera style she just needs to do it. Floor did opera in stargazers quite well so I know she can do sleeping sun, practice is the key...
Nevena Peeva
06 января 2017 года в 15:15
I don't think Floor should try to mimic Tarja. For me, her version is so breathtakingly beautiful, there's nothing more I could ask for. I can't even tell which I like better, the original or Floor's take.
Besides, anyone could mimic someone else (of course, it could not work, depending on your talent), but it takes much more skills to give something from yourself, to make it different and your own. That's what Floor does. Just listen to her performance from Master of Rock on the bonus VoS DVD, it almost made me cry.
Now, for Anette... It's not bad per se, but when I compare it to Floor and Tarja, it feels weak. And most importantly... It doesn't do much for me emotionally. So yeah, they should've left Sleeping Sun alone and played, say, Meadows of Heaven instead - she sounds so good there, I don't understand why this one was so neglected when it comes to playing it live.
Besides, anyone could mimic someone else (of course, it could not work, depending on your talent), but it takes much more skills to give something from yourself, to make it different and your own. That's what Floor does. Just listen to her performance from Master of Rock on the bonus VoS DVD, it almost made me cry.
Now, for Anette... It's not bad per se, but when I compare it to Floor and Tarja, it feels weak. And most importantly... It doesn't do much for me emotionally. So yeah, they should've left Sleeping Sun alone and played, say, Meadows of Heaven instead - she sounds so good there, I don't understand why this one was so neglected when it comes to playing it live.
Tay Hodges
02 января 2017 года в 14:17
Their new album has floor Singing it and she does it credit!! It sounds great :D
hangicsa81
16 июня 2014 года в 11:49
8
My ears are bleeding, ugh. I want to hear it with Floor, I am sure she can sing it properly! I loved Nightwish with Tarja, songs with Anette were ok ( but only studio records ) and I love Nightwish with Floor even more than with Tarja.
Vik Delson
30 ноября 2016 года в 23:46
Haters gonna hate
Dreamflight
20 января 2015 года в 22:48
U know why ? becouse Floor dont have only so sweet voice, but she is also so energic , and she can sing so well :)) !! with Floor they hit the diamond, really :)
the Anarchist
01 декабря 2014 года в 19:11
10
It´s not bad....Anette had its own style, and I understand that someone did not like
Сергей Васильковский
31 июля 2016 года в 12:30
14
Jesus Christ... My ears!!! Spring cats sing better!
Vik Delson
30 ноября 2016 года в 23:46
Haters gonna hate
Maho27
01 мая 2017 года в 20:04
5
Thanks for destroying my favorite song Anette!
Erik Nieuwenhuijzen
13 апреля 2015 года в 19:10
6
Nice song live with annette... very nice!;)
Sas AsD
14 сентября 2016 года в 14:11
8
Well, I feel sorry for Anette. It's not her fault she has to sing the songs that doesn't fit her. I prefer her version of the Siren. She does a better job at it than Floor.
Jhony Uriel ArT
19 апреля 2014 года в 18:30
6
Gosto demais da versão da Anette pra essa música !
Adar March
24 августа 2014 года в 21:16
7
I love Nightwish, I love Anette, but she couldn't sing this one.
Carlos Nogueira
19 февраля 2015 года в 02:50
I like this version, I think Anette can sing it, but with her style
Leopoldo Santos
11 октября 2014 года в 01:24
yes '-' she gets much better when singing scaretale or songs like these
ZeljkoRanilovic
06 сентября 2014 года в 10:19
I love you, Adar March, but, you are an idiot. This is amazing.
Rodrigo Monteiro
08 февраля 2017 года в 09:29
5
Just love Anette versions over older songs, simply different interpretation of originals. Thanks for uploading it!
Tatiane Almeida
04 сентября 2017 года в 11:03
5
1Tarja ♡
2 Floor ♡
3 Anette
2 Floor ♡
3 Anette
On Taka
28 апреля 2016 года в 05:38
17
Nightwish official needs to delete this video and replace it with a live footage sung by Floor Jansen, preferable in HD pls.
Kim Bolduc
26 сентября 2018 года в 15:40
Floor's Sleeping Sun performance is everywhere on youtube and it's fucking awesome, and she doesn't ''scream''. Stay bitter.
Bruno Albuquerque
07 февраля 2018 года в 17:17
Kim Bolduc actually, if you see footages of Floor singing this, she screams quite a lot close to the end, with performances able to put anyone to sleep. Disappointing as it is, yet true.
JM811Cars
21 сентября 2017 года в 04:40
Neither are Tarja
Kim Bolduc
11 июля 2017 года в 02:04
Hum, Anette was the one screaming because of her inferior vocal skills, while Floor belts flawlessly. Anette wishes she could sound like Floor :)
Сергей Васильковский
31 июля 2016 года в 12:36
Her voice is the best bait for cats in the spring ...
MetalstarX
19 февраля 2015 года в 16:38
8
Annette just didn't have the voice for Nightwish. She was too "poppy" whereas Tarja and Floor are more operatic. Perhaps the band felt that after the success of Wish I Had An Angel that a more mainstream voice was the way to go but it was the wrong choice.
Floor has always been fabulous and will put Nightwish back on the map!!!!!
Floor has always been fabulous and will put Nightwish back on the map!!!!!
Dreamflight
13 мая 2015 года в 22:42
5
Squieling pigs, if u know what i mean :DDDD
On Taka
28 апреля 2016 года в 05:41
+WeirdD ShittT
Nicely put. The vocals reminds me the sound of a pig slaughter house.
Oink Oink Uieek
Nicely put. The vocals reminds me the sound of a pig slaughter house.
Oink Oink Uieek
Escapist Wishmaster
06 октября 2015 года в 17:07
+WeirdD ShittT Who does not know ? XD
Андрей
20 сентября 2015 года в 03:22
3
чё за хрень? Товарищи- господа слушатели! Мне послышалрсь? Или взаправду? Мож я перепил? Или с ушами чего приключилось? Это кто?
Lern Korh
24 января 2015 года в 13:57
4
Мои ухи!Ужас)))
Miguel Bassman
12 января 2014 года в 20:26
2
este tema es muy bueno, pero a anette le falta mucho para poder llegar a ser algo de lo q hacia tarja, mil veces mejor floor jansen.Saludos..
Andrea Melinda Kiss
06 марта 2018 года в 09:36
1
Not bad at all! I expected something reeeeally worse based on the comments. I think she has a great voice.
But, I also noticed that the way the guitars were walking on the stage and their facial expressions tells everything about what they were thinking... (I think they didn't really like it either)
But, I also noticed that the way the guitars were walking on the stage and their facial expressions tells everything about what they were thinking... (I think they didn't really like it either)
Alena Magda
25 сентября 2016 года в 23:28
2
Das Kleid sieht aus, wie als hätte sie die Vorhänge meiner Oma abgerissen und sich umgewickelt 😆
Jana Angova
13 декабря 2016 года в 17:50
Haha! 😆
Kyo Slovakia
06 апреля 2018 года в 19:08
2
What is with the dislikes? She's not half bad. I like her more than Floor.
1. Tarja
2. Anette
3. Floor.
1. Tarja
2. Anette
3. Floor.
Иво Петров
28 января 2017 года в 18:56
1
Srsly? Official live??? Even Floor sings this song better than Anette (my respect to Anette). I recommend official live of this emblematic song to be the live from End of an Era... Please, don't ruin this song... ;~(
Flaniver Cordova
03 декабря 2013 года в 06:31
1
ME GUSTA ESTA CANCION, EN ESTA VERSION ES ENCANTADORA..AUNKE TAMN LA DE TARJA..LAS DOS SON BUENAS
Сергей Константинович
25 ноября 2017 года в 20:11
1
Мама дорогая 2008й год....
Carlos Albelo
31 июля 2017 года в 00:15
1
Bring Back Tarja!!! This one makes the sun want to keep sleeping! 👎 #Boring
fredsur83
07 мая 2017 года в 16:19
1
Qua muziek een schitterende uitvoering, qua zang daarentegen verschrikkelijk!
Stian Ivannex Davey
31 января 2014 года в 16:43
1
q horrible.... anett es un desastre incluso en su vestimenta... q feoo pero floor jansen da la talla... perfect para nightwish....
Vik Delson
30 ноября 2016 года в 23:46
Haters gonna hate
Joaco Pinto
01 ноября 2014 года в 20:43
*Que
*Anette
*Anette
Carlo di Carlogiovane
28 февраля 2017 года в 01:44
1
Only Tarja can sing this song!
teacher433
23 июля 2017 года в 20:48
1
So embarrassing...
irek weczera
31 марта 2015 года в 20:27
1
Where is Taria?
Dreamflight
20 января 2015 года в 22:52
15
I am really happy nightwish got Floor Jansen ..... becouse anette is nothing compared to Floors energic concerts full of high notes and crazy belting ... i think she fit perfectly in band after Imaginaerum, thanks to songs like last ride of day , anette u just didnt fit em
Hamster Munchies
18 июня 2015 года в 19:54
+WeirdD ShittT I'm sure we're already discussed Floor's jaw-dropping version. Anette's was just as eye-watering but for completely the opposite reason.
Mr01081960
07 января 2019 года в 20:45
0
Anette la interpreta con il suo stile molto diverso sia da tarja che da floor e personalmente mi piace molto 😘
Tobby Terence Stamp
09 июня 2018 года в 12:15
0
It's a shame somehow _Это позор какой то
Rene Callejas
27 июля 2018 года в 14:37
0
Pesimo.... pero que mal suena... que bueno que ahora con Floor mejoró todo... incluso con Floor es mejor que cuando estaba Tarja
Ángela Sevilla
20 апреля 2018 года в 20:30
0
Anette canta con dulzura y a su voz
モウタズ マターMOUTAZ MATTAR
20 октября 2018 года в 04:41
0
Not bad from the voice of beautiful annette she sing in more soul style. Also i love floor singing her version but the oreginal with terja is the best version.
Tawany olliveira
19 января 2016 года в 01:59
0
Eita voz de criança essa da Anette affss meu deus. Prefiro a tarja msm.
El Villano De La Pelicula
06 ноября 2018 года в 22:29
0
this video was made 10 years ago and the album 20 years Ago.
Mariana Mokaccino
13 мая 2018 года в 20:15
0
Esta cancion no es tu estilo xc
Hamster Munchies
18 июня 2015 года в 19:51
0
The choruses and the end of the verses are a iffy but from the start of to the middle verses weren't as bad as I was expecting.
Gardab Brubeck
02 августа 2016 года в 22:49
Not bad, but everything has been said.
btw, there are two things i see in the comments sections of every Nightwish video, Tarja was better, and some comment from you.
btw, there are two things i see in the comments sections of every Nightwish video, Tarja was better, and some comment from you.
Miguel Sandels
26 апреля 2018 года в 20:46
0
As Angry Joe would say...This sounds HORRRRRIBLE..
George Harder
16 декабря 2018 года в 21:14
0
facepalm.jpg
Anna Key
26 сентября 2018 года в 16:57
0
She does not fall into notes
mak mak
17 января 2018 года в 01:21
0
((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((
h20 44
08 января 2018 года в 21:46
0
Annette isnt a bad singer and she is surely a nice person but she never fit to nightwish. She is more a rock / pop singer. This song is so much better with floor or tarja.
Lesly Roman
29 марта 2015 года в 04:46
0
despues de oir esa rola con tarja solamente me dan ganas de deprimirme
jaider168
04 мая 2015 года в 18:38
Es verdad , realmente indignante
Pete
29 апреля 2017 года в 11:51
0
I don't dislike Annette's singing the way many others do - I do think she sounds great for certain tracks (Eva, Meadows of Heaven, etc) and did those tracks better then either of the other singers could.
But this song really is not for her. Sleeping Sun can be done by Tarja and only Tarja - and it's almost painful trying to watch any of the other singers attempt it.
But this song really is not for her. Sleeping Sun can be done by Tarja and only Tarja - and it's almost painful trying to watch any of the other singers attempt it.
Koyottaki lowbap
19 апреля 2016 года в 19:28
0
LOL
Eetu Sakarinen
24 мая 2018 года в 19:43
0
Oh no!
zahrin muhammad zain
02 октября 2016 года в 16:21
0
she should bring her soul together when singing this beautiful song like Tarja does.Tarja was great even in the live performance
Dave Mason
06 февраля 2017 года в 19:59
hahahahahahahaha .... sorry
Pavlína Štěpánová
16 декабря 2015 года в 18:15
0
hrůza, to se musí Tarja smát
Felicity Gilbert
19 марта 2017 года в 11:15
0
I actually think this is one of Annette's better live vocals 😂😂😂
Danillo Soares
19 сентября 2016 года в 12:57
0
amo essa banda ,-é a melhor
Kevin Morales
06 марта 2014 года в 16:25
0
Mejor que tarja y floor juntAS
Xtyn Xtyn
19 октября 2018 года в 10:34
0
Karaoke :(
TAK NIE
11 июня 2015 года в 20:57
0
Her voice is too commercial, too POP style. She destroying the climate of the song...
Javier Frias
17 ноября 2017 года в 03:11
0
Really???? Horrible
Mahi R
30 октября 2013 года в 20:35
0
Oh God, I love her vocal!
Mahi R
30 октября 2013 года в 20:33
0
Why judge that much! Cant see people are still enjoying the song.
Brendan Boyle
10 октября 2013 года в 14:16
0
such a shame anette left nightwish,really wanna see how floor Jensen will sing this.
Angel
02 октября 2013 года в 17:20
0
it is a hard song for anette as sleeping sun was written to suit tarja's voice which is completely different to anette's, yet anette still did a brilliant job in this performance i think
Vixen Sin
27 сентября 2013 года в 19:11
0
This is so wrong :( Tarja JUST CAN´T be replaced!
Auringonnousu
29 августа 2013 года в 12:09
0
No it's not that hard to sing...;)
Lucas Cardoso
03 августа 2013 года в 20:00
0
"Where is Emppu?" JAJAJAAA
Luivan Santos
30 июля 2013 года в 01:56
1
Omg....shes looks like the claw of IT.
Samuel Michiels
11 июля 2013 года в 03:37
0
Bye! Bye! Anette!
Lord Xeen
02 июля 2013 года в 00:47
1
Yes I feel the same, Floor took over on the Pacific Northwest stretch of the tour. Floor really did a great job on such short notice, including learning the epic Ghost Love Score which is also very difficult. I enjoy End of an Era's videos and the last tour too. Floor sings Last Ride of the Day so much better than Anette although yes, Anette did get better from her last album. She just didn't fit the band well as vocalist.
Jonne Backhaus
01 июля 2013 года в 10:03
1
Thank god there is Floor Jansen who can sing both the Turunen Songs and Anettes ;)
Thalia Sklaros
13 июня 2013 года в 21:12
0
Very Cool interpretation of our beloved Sleeping Sun! <3 Well done and Rock on!
Silver Spike
02 июня 2013 года в 19:25
0
Dude , we got used on FLOOR to be as Revamp and Afterforever
we will not get use to her if she enter Nightwish ..
Yeah , may be she can sing tarja's songs , but she is familliar to the fans .... the will not be new era ... surprise level will be 0
Tuomas don't want that , he wanted to start completely new era with new singer ........ I can guarantee that he will choose an unknown new style singer to be their next angel
we will not get use to her if she enter Nightwish ..
Yeah , may be she can sing tarja's songs , but she is familliar to the fans .... the will not be new era ... surprise level will be 0
Tuomas don't want that , he wanted to start completely new era with new singer ........ I can guarantee that he will choose an unknown new style singer to be their next angel
Tony Montana
02 июня 2013 года в 19:01
0
I can´t think anyone better than this dutch amazon with high and loud dramatic soprano voice.
Silver Spike
02 июня 2013 года в 18:53
0
Yeah Sorry , I mistaken :) I meant Tarot to Nightwish !!
Dude , Female fronted metal bands are known each for their unique beautiful singer , like when you said EPICA == you mean Simone , Imagine that Simone will go and sing for Nightwish !!!! it will be so bad thing , I will think for her as commercial person ..
Nightwish is unique band and MUST have a unique new singer
what do you think ??
Dude , Female fronted metal bands are known each for their unique beautiful singer , like when you said EPICA == you mean Simone , Imagine that Simone will go and sing for Nightwish !!!! it will be so bad thing , I will think for her as commercial person ..
Nightwish is unique band and MUST have a unique new singer
what do you think ??
Tony Montana
02 июня 2013 года в 17:32
0
You mean Tarot to Nightwish?
Silver Spike
02 июня 2013 года в 12:20
0
Dude , you are comparing NIGHTWISH to REVAMP !!
where is the logic in your comparison too !!
where is the logic in your comparison too !!
Tony Montana
02 июня 2013 года в 10:53
0
So Hietala can have his own band, but Floor can´t. You are not very logical here.
Silver Spike
02 июня 2013 года в 10:14
0
Dude , Floor has her own band ( Revamp )
Nightwish must have a stand-alone unique singer for them ...
They don't want to have a common singer with another band , I know Tuomas's way of thinking ....when they kicked out tarja , they could be able to use Floor as replacement , ( Tuomas said in an interview that he is a long time fan of Floor ) , BUT they didn't pick her !! They wanted a singer that could represent NIGHTWISH only ...which will make the band stand-alone ..
Nightwish must have a stand-alone unique singer for them ...
They don't want to have a common singer with another band , I know Tuomas's way of thinking ....when they kicked out tarja , they could be able to use Floor as replacement , ( Tuomas said in an interview that he is a long time fan of Floor ) , BUT they didn't pick her !! They wanted a singer that could represent NIGHTWISH only ...which will make the band stand-alone ..
Tony Montana
01 июня 2013 года в 18:35
0
Well, we shall see, I think it´s impossible to find better than Floor.
Silver Spike
01 июня 2013 года в 16:39
0
No , Floor is just a temporary replacement , they will bring brand new singer with brand new voice style to replace Anette
1malakian
10 мая 2013 года в 06:20
0
I am really looking forward to listening to Floor sing this song and "She is my Sin" because this rendition and every other by Anette is pure crap.
alanbanterfc nagadewa
26 апреля 2013 года в 13:19
0
mantep
michael wargo
18 мая 2016 года в 21:34
6
LOVE THIS BAND AND ANETTE AWESOME AS F$#K THEY ARE!!
Sayuri Li
23 апреля 2013 года в 22:08
0
Tuomas never should've allowed Anetter destroy this song and herself, she is a great singer , I canoot imagine amaranth with Tarja, because every song is for a different singer!!
Tony Montana
17 апреля 2013 года в 10:37
0
I think they are thinking of Floor Jansen.
tmcmellon
23 марта 2013 года в 03:09
0
This is a fucking train wreck no matter what range her voice is supposed to be good at.
What are the guys in the band thinking while this is going on???
What are the guys in the band thinking while this is going on???
Karo G
18 марта 2013 года в 15:07
0
Anette is better in "her" songs, so why she sings old Nightwish?!?! WHY?!
Valdi
03 февраля 2013 года в 02:44
0
Stop me, stop me because her murderer!
PapillonNoir
21 января 2013 года в 21:18
0
Tarja is soprano so she sings in high key hitting high notes. Antte is not, so she sings with lowered tune hitting really beatiful low notes. What's wrong with that? And yes, i like it.
Omar Guillermo
11 января 2013 года в 20:34
0
[Now i'll make a comment about how much better Tarja is in order to make me feel look like an illustrated music taster]
deadlywiper
08 января 2013 года в 04:05
0
Anette voice is like low battery :( Tarja was a goddess......My god this is a shame !!!
Razvan Sid
02 января 2013 года в 15:52
0
very true :) i love nightwish in general...
TroubleTribal
06 ноября 2012 года в 20:26
0
Ужасно, просто отвратительно... зачем уродовать песню, если на нее не хватает голоса. Это выглядит тщетной попыткой допрыгнуть до Тарьи
Isäntä \m/
05 ноября 2012 года в 22:24
0
wtf are u want she cant be Tarja... but this is great !! :D
Vayia Xanthopoulou
04 ноября 2012 года в 17:43
0
She is not like Tarja!
Viviana Torres
24 августа 2012 года в 15:56
0
i think that tarja sings this song better but it is too dificult, you judge anette but I would swear that you can't sing this song neither, so the only one who can sing this song so good and beautiful is tarja but anette does her best =D
Eastrenn
21 июля 2012 года в 00:45
0
I think the nightwish's fans who prefere tarja because they knew tarja before anette. It's to different to compare
Ana Collazo
19 июля 2012 года в 10:21
0
I think Tuomas is just incredible, and he is the real soul of Nightwish...
But I have to say that Anette has nothing to do with this song...
This is just not for her voice.
But well... Each one has their own tastes. ^^
But I have to say that Anette has nothing to do with this song...
This is just not for her voice.
But well... Each one has their own tastes. ^^
SilverStar_Gaming
11 июня 2012 года в 06:15
0
These old songs are so hard for Anette to sing. Keep in mind that they were written for Tarja Turunen's voice, not hers. Anette just doesn't have that high voice range. That said, Comparing Tarja to Anette is apples and oranges. It's too harsh on Anette to tear her up over it. Another factor here is that Sleeping Sun is VERY VERY Difficult. Telling Anette you have to sing it like Tarja in End of an Era is totally unfair. She's judged much too harshly by old fans, and I'm a HUGE Tarja fan.